Eco-SystemApproach for Assessing Agrarian Sustainability in Bulgaria

Authors: H. Bachev, ORCID ID 0000000305557468, Doctor of Sciences (Economics), Professor, Institute of Agricultural Economics, Sofia, Bulgaria
G. Kharlamova, ORCID ID 000000033614712X, PhD in Economics, Associate Professor, Department of Economic Cybernetics, Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv.

Abstract: Ecosystem approach has been increasingly incorporated in the management and evaluation of sustainability levels in general and in agriculture in particular. Despite enormous progress in the theory an d practice of this new area, still there is no consensus on how to assess the sustainability of agro-ecosystems due to diverse understandings, approaches, methods, employed data, etc. In Bulgaria there are practically no in-depth studies on sustainability level of diverse agro-eco-systems. This articles assesses the sustainability level of agro-ecosystems of different type in Bulgaria. A holistic hierarchical framework for assessing integral, economic, social and ecological sustainability of agro-ecosystems is suggested including 17 principles, 35 criteria, and 46 indicators and reference values. Assessment is made on overall and aspects sustainability of large (agro)ecosystems in four geographic regions, and particular main and specific types of agro-ecosystems of the country. The assessment is based on first- hand information collected though in-depth interviews with the managers of “typical” farms in the respective ago-ecosystems. The study has found out that there is a considerable differentiation in the level of integral sustainability in agricultural ecosystems of different types. There are also substantial variations in the levels of economic, social and ecological sustainability of agro- ecosystems of different type, and the critical indicators enhancing or deterring overall and particular sustainability of individual agro-ecosystems. Results of the integral agrarian sustainability level based on the micro agro-ecosystem (farm) data, are similar to the previous assessment based on the aggregate sectoral (statistical, etc.) data. Having in mind the importance of holistic assessments of this kind for improving agrarian sustainability, farm management and agrarian policies, they are to be expended and their precision and representation increased.

Key words: agro-ecosystem, sustainability, assessment, economic, social, ecological, Bulgaria

Received: 16-02-2019

1st Revision: 20-02-2019

Accepted: 23-03-2019



Bachev, H. (2009): Governing of Agro-ecosystem Services. Modes, Efficiency, Perspectives, VDM Verlag Dr.Muller Aktiengesellscaft & Co. KG, Saarbrucken.
Bachev H. (2010): Governance of Agrarian Sustainability, New York: Nova Science Publishers.
Bachev H. (2016): A Framework for Assessing Sustainability of Farming Enterprises Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, Spring Issue, Vol XI, 1(39), 24-43.
Bachev H. (2016): Defining and Assessing the Governance of Agrarian Sustainability, Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, Volume VII, Issue 4(18), 797–816.
Bachev H. (2017): Sustainability Level of Bulgarian Farms, Bulgarian Journal of Agricultural Science, 23 (1), 1–13.
Bachev H. (2017): Sustainability of Bulgarian Farming Enterprises during EU CAP Implementation, Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, 2(48), 422–451.
Bachev H. (2018): The Sustainability of Farming Enterprises in Bulgaria, Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Bachev H. (2018): Institutional Environment and Climate Change Impacts on Sustainability of Bulgarian Agriculture, Bulgarian Journal of Agricultural Science, 24 (4), 523–536.
Bachev H., Ivanov B., Toteva D., Sokolova E.(2016): Agrarian Sustainability and its Governance – Understanding, Evaluation, Improvement, Journal of Environmental Management and Tourism, Vol. 7, issue 4 (16), 639–663.
Bachev H., B. Ivanov, D.Toteva and E.Sokolova (2017): Agrarian sustainability in Bulgaria – economic, social and ecological aspects, Bulgarian Journal of Agricultural Science, 23 (4), 519–525.
Bachev H. and D.Terziev (2017): Environmental Sustainability of Agricultural Farms in Bulgaria, Journal of Environmental Management and Tourism, Vol 8 No 5 (2017): JEMT Volume VIII Issue 5(21) Fall 2017, 968–994
Bachev, H., Terziev, D. (2018): A Study on Institutional, Market and Natural Environment Impact on Agrarian Sustainability in Bulgaria, Journal of Environmental Management and Tourism, Volume IX, Issue 3 (27), 452–478.
Bachev, H., Terziev, D. (2018). A Study on Agrarian Sustainability Impact of Governance Modes in Bulgaria. Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, Volume XIII, Spring, 1(55): 227–257.
Belcher K. (1999): Agroecosystem sustainability: an integrated modelling approach, PhD Thesis, HARVEST, University of Saskatchewan.
Bohlen P. and G. House (2009): Sustainable Agroecosystem Management: Integrating Ecology, Economics, and Society, CRC Press.
De Oliveira A. (editor) (2018): Sustainability of Agroecosystems, IntechOpen, DOI: 10.5772/intechopen.70964
FAO (2013): SAFA. Sustainability Assessment of Food and Agriculture systems indicators, FAO.
Fuentes M. (2004): Farms Management Indicators Related to the Policy Dimension in the European Union, OECD Expert Meeting on Farm Management Indicators and the Environment, 8-12 March 2004, New Zealand.
Ikerd J. (2015): On Defining Sustainable Agriculture, SARE.
Hanna S., I. Osborne-Lee, G. Cesaretti, R.Magdy, T.Khalile (2016): Ecological Agro-ecosystem Sustainable Development in Relationship to Other Sectors in the Economic System, and Human Ecological Footprint and Imprint,Agriculture and Agricultural Science Procedia, Vol. 8, 17–30.
Hayati D.Z. Ranjbar, and E. Karami (2010): Measuring Agricultural Sustainability, in E. Lichtfouse (ed.), Biodiversity, Biofuels, Agroforestry and Conservation Agriculture, 73, Sustainable Agriculture Reviews 5, Springer Science+Business Media B.V., 73–100.
Ivanov, B., T. Radev, D. Vachevska, P. Borisov (2009): Agricultural Sustainability – ASVIWI. Avangard Prima, Sofia.
Lopez-Ridauira S., Masera O., Astier M. (2002): Evaluating the sustainability of complex socio-environmental systems. The MESMIS framework. Ecological indicators 2: 135–148.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (MEA) (2005): Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis. Washington, DC: Island Press.
Oelbermann M. (editor) (2014): Sustainable agroecosystems in climate change mitigation, Wageningen Academic Publishers,
Rezear K., A. Osmani; P. Borisov, D. Skunca (2018): Beyond the Metropolis: Farmers’ empowering as a challenge of Peri-urban areas, European Journal of Economics and Management Sciences, Vol 3,
Ramirez-Carrillo E., O. Lopez-Corona , J. Toledo-Roy, J. Lovett, F. Leon-Gonzalez, L. Osorio-Olvera, J. Equihua, E. Robredo,
A. Frank, R. Dirzo, V. Perez-Cirera (2018): Assessing sustainability in North America’s ecosystems using criticality and information theory, PLOS, Published: July 16
Sauvenier X., J. Valekx, N. Van Cauwenbergh, E. Wauters, H.Bachev. K.Biala, C. Bielders, V. Brouckaert, V. Garcia-Cidad,
S. Goyens, M. Hermy, E. Mathijs, B. Muys, M. Vanclooster. and A. Peeters (2005): Framework for Assessing Sustainability Levels in Belgium Agricultural Systems – SAFE, Belgium Science Policy, Brussels.
Sidle R., W. Benson, J., Carriger and T. Kamaic (2013): Broader perspective on ecosystem sustainability: Consequences for decision making, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA., 110(23): 9201–9208.
Terziev D., D. Radeva, & Y. Kazakova (2018): A new look on agricultural sustainability and food safety: Economic viability, in
BACHEV, S. CHE, S. YANCHEVA (Editors) Agrarian and Rural Revitalisation Issues in China and Bulgaria, KSP Books, 231–242.
Todorova K. and R.Treziyska (2018): Agricultural sustainability through provision of agri-environment public goods: The role of farmers as decision-makers, in H. BACHEV, S. CHE, S. YANCHEVA (Editors) Agrarian and Rural Revitalisation Issues in China and Bulgaria, KSP Books, 253–267.
VanLoon, G., Patil, S. and Hugar, L. (2005): Agricultural Sustainability: Strategies for Assessment. London: SAGE Publications.
Zvyatkova D. and A. Sarov (2018): Process of Transfer of Family Farms for Sustainability of Agricultural Cooperatives, in “Role of Family Business for Sustainable Rural Development, Agrarian University, 61 (2), 125–134.